We the Question

On citizenship, inheritance, and who gets counted as human

---

Author's Note:
Some poems begin with memory. Others begin with grief. This one began with a question: What becomes of a promise when its words remain the same, but its meaning begins to shift?

I wrote this as an immigrant, a naturalized American, and a mother.

---

I crossed an ocean
believing a promise.

Not that America was perfect.

Only that perfection
was never the requirement.

A promise is not measured
by whether it is kept,
but by whether it still remembers
what it once swore to become.

I took the oath.

Raised my hand.

Learned that citizenship
could be chosen,
that belonging
might grow larger than blood.

Now the highest court does not erase the promise.
It shifts the weight of it.

Not with a single clear break,
but by loosening what once felt fixed,
rearranging the distance
between birth and belonging,
between arrival and recognition,
until protection feels conditional
without ever announcing itself gone.

The language stays intact.
The shape beneath it does not.

The oldest exclusions rarely return
with their original names.

They arrive
as restraint,
as order,
as constitutional patience.

But beneath the language
the familiar outline remains,

the slow drawing inward
of who is fully held.

I think of my children.

Not because they owe this country affection.

Love cannot be compelled,
and disillusionment
is its own inheritance.

I think instead
of every child
whose first breath
may now be held
under interpretation.

As though arrival
requires review.

As though a cradle
could be provisional.

Nations tell stories
about themselves.

Some widen the circle
until it disappears.

Others learn to tighten it
without ever naming the hand that does so.

Perhaps that has always been
the unfinished sentence.

Not We the People

but the question
that moves beneath it:

which people,
by what forgetting?

And still, beneath argument and adjustment,
a quieter truth persists:

a child arrives
without permission.

The rest
is what we decide to make of that fact.